Compare the features and requirements of Thermo Scientific Pierce Classic, Crosslink and Direct IP Kits to determine which one is most appropriate for an intended immunoprecipitation experiment and available source of antibody.
What is immunoprecipitation?
Immunoprecipitation (IP) is small scale affinity purification of antigen using a specific antibody. Traditional IP involves incubation of antibody with a protein mixture containing the antigen, followed by capture of the antibody:antigen complex to Protein A or Protein G immobilized on beaded agarose resin. After washing to remove nonbound (presumably undesired) components of the sample, antibody and antigen are recovered by boiling the beaded affinity resin in sample loading buffer for analysis by SDS-PAGE.

How are the Thermo Scientific Pierce IP Kits different from traditional IP?
The three main kinds of Pierce IP Kits, like the traditional IP method, require a specific antibody and use beaded agarose affinity resin for immunoprecipitation of the antigen. Unlike in the traditional IP method, all three Pierce IP Kits provide a complete set of reagents and convenient spin columns and collection tubes to perform successful IP experiments with ease. The Crosslink and Direct IP Kits comprise two different methods for covalent immobilization of the antibody to the agarose resin, enabling purification of antigens without the usual co-elution of the antibody heavy and light chain fragments.
What is the key difference between the Crosslink and Direct IP Kits?
Both the Crosslink IP Kit and the Direct IP Kit allow covalent attachment of the IP antibody to the agarose resin, enabling purification of antigen without the usual co-elution of antibody heavy and light chain fragments.
- The Crosslink IP Method uses crosslinking to covalently attach the antibody to the Protein A/G Agarose Resin. As such, the method requires an IP antibody of a species and subclass that can be bound by either Protein A or Protein G. (See Protein A and Protein G binding characteristics by antibody species and class).
- The Direct IP Method uses reductive amination to directly couple antibody primary amino groups to an aldehyde-activated agarose support called AminoLink Plus Coupling Resin. Because the coupling reaction occurs to any primary amine, the antibody must be pure – that is, it must be free of amine-containing buffers (e.g., Tris) and all other proteins such as BSA and gelatin. Although pure antibody is required for the Direct IP Method, there are no species or subclass requirements because coupling is not dependent on Protein A or Protein G binding affinities. Chicken IgY, human IgE and IgM, or any purified protein can be immobilized to the AminoLink Plus Coupling Resin.
How do these different IP methods affect results?
 |
|
Comparison of Thermo Scientific Pierce IP Kit methods. Identical amounts of affinity-purified goat anti-GFP antibody and and cell lysate were used with identical amounts of respective agarose beads for purification by the three different kit methods. E1-E3 denote three successive elution fractions electrophoresed on a 12% polyacrylamide reducing gel and stained with GelCode Blue Stain Reagent. MW = Molecular Weight Marker. |
|
Comparision of Immunoprecipitation Methods: The following table compares the key features of traditional "do-it-yourself" immunoprecipation techniques to the Thermo Scientific Pierce IP Kits. Consideration of these features can help to determine which method is most appropriate for the available reagents and downstream application.
|
|
Feature
|
Traditional
IP Method
|
Pierce
Classic IP Kit
|
Pierce
Crosslink IP Kit
|
Pierce
Direct IP Kit
|
|
Uses high binding capacity resin
|
Variable ¹
|
Yes
(Protein A/G Plus)
|
Yes
(Protein A/G Plus)
|
Yes
(AminoLink Plus)
|
|
Crosslinker mediated immobilization
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
(DSS)
|
No
|
|
Requires purified antibody in amine-free and protein-free storage solution
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
|
Antibody is covalently attached to agarose resin
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Antibody is oriented
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
|
Antibody elutes with antigen
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
No
|
|
Antigen recovery method
|
Boiling w/ SDS
(Low pH)
|
Low pH elution
(Boiling w/ SDS)
|
Low pH elution
|
Low pH elution
|
|
Relative antigen recovery ²
|
Variable
|
Highest
|
Medium
|
High
|
|
Immobilized antibody can be reused
|
No
|
No
|
Possible ³
|
Possible ³
|
|
1 Commercially available resins vary in binding capacity and performance for IP assays.
2 Antigen yield is depends on the activity of the antibody, specific binding conditions and the immobiliztion method used.
3 It is possible to reuse the prepared antibody affinity resin if the antibody remains functional following low pH elution.
|
Related Thermo Scientific Pierce Products:
|
Product
|
Description
|
|
Co-Immunoprecipitation Kit
|
Same components as the Direct IP Kit but includes optimized protocol for co-immunoprecipitation, including discussion of controls
|
|
HA-Tag IP Kit
|
For IP or Co-IP involving HA-tagged antigen; contains covalently immobilized anti-HA-tag antibody agarose resin
|
|
c-Myc-Tag IP Kit
|
For IP or Co-IP involving c-Myc-tagged antigen; contains covalently immobilized anti-c-Myc-tag antibody agarose resin
|
|
Biotinylated Protein Pull-Down Kit
|
For pull-down affinity purification of interaction complexes involving a biotin-tagged protein; contains streptavidin agarose resin
|
|
GST Protein Pull-Down Kit
|
For pull-down affinity purification of interaction complexes involving a GST-tagged protein; contains glutathione agarose resin
|
|
His-Protein Pull-Down Kit
|
For pull-down affinity purification of interaction complexes involving a His-tagged protein; contains cobalt-chelate agarose resin
|
|